Hunting and fishing are part of Colorado’s outdoor recreation history and culture, but this year voters are being asked whether those activities should also be in the state’s constitution.

Amendment 83, also known as the Right to Hunt and Fish Amendment, will appear on ballots statewide and, if passed, would make hunting and fishing “by traditional methods” a constitutional right and would also make those methods of take the “preferred means” of managing wildlife in the state.

Coloradans for Responsible Wildlife Management Executive Director Dan Gates, whose organization supports Amendment 83, said this initiative is in response to previous ballot measures and regulatory actions that have sought to place restrictions on hunting and fishing.

“The main reason to support Amendment 83 is because of the constant attacks and assaults on hunting and fishing that we’ve seen over the last 30 years, but specifically over the last eight or 10 years,” Gates said. “We’ve seen that through the General Assembly and through the (Colorado Parks and Wildlife) Commission and at the ballot — attempts to erode and degrade Colorado Parks and Wildlife’s ability to manage wildlife resources, the 78 game species, through hunting and fishing.”

Gates points to examples like a failed 2024 ballot initiative to ban hunting of mountain lions, bobcats and lynx and ongoing discussion on limiting or banning hunting of beavers. He said there have been a number of similar actions taken that have happened over the years that led to this proposed amendment.

“This is an attempt to slow or just completely thwart those efforts and continue to leave all these management decisions up to the managing agency,” Gates said. “If they decided we shouldn’t do any of it, then we shouldn’t do it as long as science says that we shouldn’t.”

Colorado Hunters and Anglers for Sensible Wildlife Conservation President Eric Washburn, who opposes the amendment, said hunting and fishing are already established rights under state law. Washburn, a hunter himself, said he does not believe hunting rights are being threatened.

“If you look at Colorado state law, hunting and fishing is explicitly protected in Colorado state law,” Washburn said. “There’s no real risk to hunting and fishing. That’s what’s so mystifying about this whole exercise is that it’s already protected in state law and there’s really no threat to it.”

TRADITIONAL METHODS

One concern raised by Washburn and other groups opposing Amendment 83 is the phrase “traditional methods” used in the proposed amendment.

That language, Washburn said, could be interpreted to bring back previously banned methods of hunting and fishing that were considered cruel or excessive.

“If you look at Colorado’s history, there are a lot of pretty awful things that Coloradans have done in the past to harvest and kill wildlife,” Washburn said. “Subsequently, Coloradans recognized that those were not either ethical or they were too cruel and they banned them. You think of leg hold traps, which were banned by ballot measure in 1992. You think of bear baiting, the spring bear hunt, using hounds to hunt bears, all banned by ballot measure in 1996. You think of wildlife killing contests that were banned by the CPW Commission in 2020. All those things were traditional methods of hunting and harvesting wildlife.”

Supporters of the amendment, like Gates, say this is an unfounded fear. Gates said the amendment is intended to only protect methods of hunting and fishing that are allowed if and when voters pass it.

“Traditional methods are anything that’s allowed at time of passage,” Gates said. “So if it’s legal now, that’s what traditional would mean. They want to turn around and act like traditional is going to bring back bear hunting or it’s going to bring back trapping. For that matter, you could actually even be facetious about it and say, ‘Well, I guess we can run elk off of a cliff and stab them with a spear at the bottom,’ because that was traditional back in the day. This is legal methods of take at time of passage.”

Colorado would not be the first state to implement a constitutional right to hunt and fish, Gates said. There are 24 states with that right in the state constitution, with 14 that use the “traditional methods” phrase, he said.

“This language was taken exactly from those other states,” Gates said. “Not at any level did those other individuals in those other states bring out anything that was from the past.”

That does not mean that couldn’t happen in Colorado, Washburn argues. He said the state has been more proactive than others in banning hunting methods that were considered unethical than in other states.

“None of those states have banned any of these practices,” Washburn said. “So if you put a constitutional amendment in place in those states that says we’re protecting traditional methods, you’re not overturning existing bans because existing bans haven’t been enacted in those states.”

He also said Colorado’s bans are statutory, which could be overridden because Amendment 83 is a constitutional amendment.

SCIENTIFIC WILDLIFE CONSERVATION

While this proposed amendment would create a constitutional right to hunt and fish, it explicitly preserves the right of the state to regulate hunting and fishing for “scientific wildlife conservation and management.”

Coming up with bans or limits on hunting and fishing is fine, Gates said, so long as it is based in science.

“The only science that should be relevant is what the agency that is managing those wildlife species and the habitat and the resources from a scientific standpoint — not from citizen science, not from ballot box biology, not from checking a box on something,” Gates said. “We want to leave it in the hands of the agency and under the statute. We want to codify what the statute already says and make sure it’s more difficult for the animal rights extremists to turn around and change or alter that right.”

Washburn said he does not believe CPW has always managed wildlife based on sound science, but rather based on what different interest groups, including hunters and anglers, have wanted.

“The reason I worked on the gray wolf reintroduction is because chronic wasting disease in Colorado is out of control,” Washburn said. “It’s out of control because we have eliminated nature’s mechanism for removing disease from ungulate herds and that is apex predation. If you look at the documented effects of wolves and of mountain lions, you understand that, in fact, the scientific thing to do is to stop killing mountain lions and to reintroduce wolves.”

Washburn said Amendment 83 also limits CPW’s ability to manage wildlife by making hunting and fishing its preferred management tool. For many species, he said, the best option to help them recover is not killing them.

“If you think about Colorado, we have hundreds and hundreds of species in Colorado now that have declined dramatically,” Washburn said. “Even CPW admits they need special conservation help if they’re ever going to recover. Many of those species are headed toward extinction now. To create a preference for hunting and fishing as a wildlife management tool doesn’t make any sense at all.”

How CPW chooses to manage wildlife is something that should be left up to the agency, Gates argues. He said it isn’t hunters and anglers who are tying the agency’s hands, but animal rights activists, which is why this amendment is needed.

“We haven’t filed petitions to turn around and undermine or circumvent CPW,” Gates said. “We haven’t gone to the Legislature to turn around and try to take management tools or restrict or prohibit hunting. They have. Those are the same ones that are coming out and saying that this is going to restrict CPW. They’re the ones who have been trying to restrict CPW.”

At the end of the day, Gates said CPW is going to be left to manage Colorado’s wildlife whether the amendment passes or not. He said he hopes they will be given the tools to do so effectively.

“We should let the experts manage our wildlife and our natural resources,” Gates said. “The only way we’re going to be able to do that, in our belief, is to codify this (right to hunt and fish) in the constitution.”

Amendment 83 text

Shall there be an amendment to the Colorado Constitution creating a constitutional right to hunt, fish, and harvest fish and wildlife by traditional methods, including all species of fish and wildlife managed by the state except non-game species, endangered species, or any species that is illegal to hunt under federal law, and, in connection therewith, establishing hunting and fishing as the preferred means of managing fish and wildlife populations; and preserving the right of the state to regulate hunting, fishing, and wildlife management if necessary for sound scientific wildlife conservation and management, public safety, or to preserve the future of hunting and fishing opportunities for all species?

Share.

Comments are closed.