First one looks like a pumpkinseed to me, second one looks like one too but also has a lot more going on.

Fished out of creeks in Northwest Arkansas watersheds

Posted by gavalo01

3 Comments

  1. WinnebagoViking on

    My guess for #2 would be a red breasted sunfish but I’m not sure.

    Edit to clarify which fish I was discussing.

  2. The-Great-Calvino on

    I would also guess Pumpkinseed and Redbreast. If you want a professional answer – post over at r/sunfishspecies . They always get the right identification

  3. Photo 1 appears to be a hybrid, pretty common with the Lepomis genus. To me, it looks like a Green Sunfish X Longear hybrid.

    Photo 2 is definitely a Longear sunfish.

    Both Pumpkinseed and Redbreast sunfish are non native to the state or Arkansas. There are records of both, but few and far between.

Leave A Reply